CD Reviews

Vivian Girls | Share the Joy

Polyvinyl (2011)

By LIZ PELLY | June 7, 2011

3.5 Stars

In 2008, Brooklyn's Vivian Girls pioneered a new breed of quick, punky '60s girl-group pop, inspiring a resurgence of distortion-heavy garage sounds over the next two years. But on Share the Joy — the band's third full-length, and first record for Polyvinyl — the trio scales back the fuzz and ramps up the psychedelia, offering their 10 tightest, most introspective songs yet. Share the Joy opens with "The Other Girls," six minutes of pop gloom wherein guitarist Cassie Ramone muses on avoiding gender stereotypes. "I don't want to be like the other girls/I don't want to lose myself/I just wanna spend my time inside my mind," she sings, as subtle repetitions of "the other girls, the other girls" and "my mind, my mind" create a kaleidoscopic mantra. The record stays similarly dark on "Sixteen Ways," where Ramone narrates from the perspective of a woman grieving the murder of her 16 children. In contrast to the record's general psych-pop, "Take It as It Comes" is a clear outlier: it's straight-up Shangri-Las, alternating between hooky harmonies and minimal verses about boy troubles sung by bassist Katy Goodman (who plays a boy-obsessed character) and Ramone (whose urgent, level-headed advice is clearly the main point). The indulgent aspects of the track feel like a joke when juxtaposed with the dark, spaced-out guitar solos on "Vanishing of Time," or the morbid lyricism of "Death." Now three records into their career, Vivian Girls' influence has often been misunderstood and underappreciated. Some pin their influence to "lo-fi" production qualities rather than innovative fusing of varied pop sources. Pitchfork once pegged them as successful due to "ideal timing" at the "onset of the lo-fi resurgence," but that's bullshit —Vivian Girls helped create that resurgence. The trio's strongest asset has always been inspired, thoughtfully crafted pop songs, which Share the Joy should finally make clear.

Topics: CD Reviews , Music, Vivian Girls, Vivian Girls, More

| More

Add Comment

HTML Prohibited

Friends' Activity

Popular

Most Viewed

See more deals

view all

[ 10/05 ] "Mixed Taste: Tag-team Lectures on Unrelated Topics: Robot Opera and Clam Chowder" @ Remis Auditorium, Museum of Fine Arts

[ 10/05 ] The Antlers + Explosions in the Sky @ Orpheum Theatre

[ 10/05 ] Big River: The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn @ Lyric Stage Company of Boston

ARTICLES BY LIZ PELLY

PRINCE RAMA RISE FROM BOSTON'S UNDERGROUND | October 05, 2011
Before Animal Collective's Avey Tare discovered their bouncy, Bollywood-inspired psychedelia at SXSW 2010, the group Prince Rama channeled "Now Age" chants and sang Sanskrit in Jamaica Plain houses and DIY art spaces.

INTERVIEW: JAMES BLAKE'S DUB SOFT-SHOE | September 28, 2011
Poised in a distinctive middle ground between leftfield electronica and soulful R&B, 23-year-old Londoner James Blake has been making a name for himself of late.

CAMPUS SAFE SPACES OFFER COMFY COUCHES AND OPEN MINDS | September 28, 2011
Two months into freshman year, I was sitting in a friend's dorm room when Melissa, the broadcast journalism student who lived down the hall, burst into the room. She was near tears.

TWIN SISTER | IN HEAVEN | September 20, 2011
It's one of 2011's finest pop records: 10 tracks of dreamy, weirdo hi-fi pop that grooves, sparkles, and hums with clipped beats and smooth drums.

SOMERVILLE'S FIRST ARTSHARE DELIVERS | September 14, 2011
Instead of buying into harvests of organic fruits and vegetables, shareholders pay a one-time fee of $300 for nine original pieces by local artists.

See all articles by: LIZ PELLY

Most Viewed

Most Emailed

INTERVIEW: JAMES BLAKE'S DUB SOFT-SHOE
Poised in a distinctive middle ground between leftfield electronica and soulful R&B, 23-year-old Londoner James Blake has been making a name for himself of late.

MISFITS | THE DEVIL'S RAIN
The reason there hasn't been a new Misfits record of all original material in a dozen years is because without Glenn Danzig, it's just not the Misfits.

PHOTOS: OCCUPY BOSTON DEMONSTRATIONS, FROM DEWEY SQUARE TO THE FINANCIAL DISTRICT
Participants in the “Occupy Boston” demonstrations (in association with the "Occupy Wall Street" movement) organizing at Dewey Square and participating in marches and protests throughout Boston's financial district.

BOSTON'S RAP CLASS OF 2011
The announcement of last year's Rap Class rang so loudly that we had to step back in the arena and cause more noise.

PHOTOS: OCCUPY BOSTON PLANS FINANCIAL DISTRICT TAKE-OVER
Hundreds of fiscally wary citizens gathered on Boston Common Tuesday, September 27, to organize a lasting protest occupation of Boston’s financial district.

INTERVIEW: JAMES BLAKE'S DUB SOFT-SHOE
Poised in a distinctive middle ground between leftfield electronica and soulful R&B, 23-year-old Londoner James Blake has been making a name for himself of late.

LATEST SLIDESHOWS