CD Reviews

Sonic Youth

Rather Ripped | Geffen

By NICK SYLVESTER | June 6, 2006

3.5 Stars

DAYDREAM NOTIONS: There’s less teenage riot and more pinpoint dissonance on Sonic Youth’s best since ’95’s Washing Machine.

We’re allowed to like albums about getting old but never being old, so I don’t know why this one works — SY’s most openly “mature” disc, possibly their best since ’95’s Washing Machine, maybe even the almighty Daydream Nation. The clean, nimble strumming that opens “Reena” and Kim Gordon’s first belt (“You keep me coming home again”) and the way she holds the “gain” of “again” instead of letting the note resolve really couldn’t serve as a better proem: less teenage riot, more pinpoint dissonance; fewer facefucking abstractions, more hand-in-hand face-to-face. Two songs later, Thurston Moore asks, “Do you believe in a second chance?” Hell if I know what adult-oriented themes he’s hitting on — this is a ballad, by the way — but for the first time maybe ever, I wish I did. What’s funny is that Moore goes the opposite direction, too. “I tore your heart out from your chest/Replaced it with a grenade blast,” he sings in “Incinerate,” whose billowing guitars would pass for Dinosaur Jr.’s before SY’s. I’d call it bad high-school poetry if it weren’t so perfectly bad — as if SY were artifying high-school poetry, turning it into its own genre, something I’ve thought all along. No wonder Geffen reissued their first albums this year.

On the Web
Sonic Youth: http://www.sonicyouth.com/

Topics: CD Reviews , Science and Technology, Technology, Sonic Youth, More

| More

Friends' Activity

Popular

Most Viewed

See more deals

view all

[ 02/19 ] The Addams Family @ Shubert Theatre

[ 02/19 ] American Lamb Jam Tour @ Charles Hotel

[ 02/19 ] Boston Ballet in "Simply Sublime" @ Opera House

More Information

Sonic Youth, "Reena" (Windows Media Player)

Sonic Youth, "Incinerate" (Windows Media Player)

Sonic Youth, "Do You Believe in the Rapture?" (Windows Media Player)

ARTICLES BY NICK SYLVESTER

PUNK ROCK REDUX | April 01, 2008
Try reimagining early punk as some physically intense and massively popular athletic contest.

ADOLESCENT FUNKS | February 19, 2008
Bradford Cox reminds me of my man Polyphemus — not just the one Odysseus conned in the cave but the one posted up in the countryside and pining in song for the sea nymph Galatea.

POP IN A HARD PLACE | December 16, 2008
The norms Black Dice resist are significant and strong and worth resisting.

BURIAL | December 26, 2007
Dubstep has been given its Dizzee Rascal moment with the release of Burial’s Untrue , the elusive London producer’s second album.

BROOKLYN CALLING | December 10, 2007
Below are new sounds from four very different Brooklyn acts.

See all articles by: NICK SYLVESTER

Most Viewed

Most Emailed

ANARCHISTIC AND SELF-TRAINED, ARE STREET MEDICS THE FUTURE OF FIRST AID?
April 25, 2009: outside of the IMF/World Bank meeting in Washington, DC, police with batons are attacking a group of protesters.

HAVE YOU HEARD ANY GOOD WHITNEY HOUSTON JOKES YET?
Too soon?

THE WEEK’S NEGLECTED PRESS RELEASES
Another slog through the PR dregs — because if I didn't do it, who would?

WHY THE REPUBLICAN EMBRACE OF JUST ONE CATHOLIC ISSUE IS THE HEIGHT OF HYPOCRISY
We like men in dresses as much as the next person.

THE OVERDUB TAMPERING COMMITTEE
Armed with an idea, a hastily written manifesto, a press release, and some software to disguise my computer's IP address, I was able to raise the question, "How do you know that what you're illegally downloading is the actual music it claims to be?" This is a story about how my pop-music infatuation led me to fabricating a web of lies I called the Overdub Tampering Committee.