Santigold | Master Of My Make-Believe

Downtown/Atlantic (2012)
By DAN WEISS  |  April 24, 2012
3.0 3.0 Stars


Holding the torch for unbridled eclecticism when spontaneity was out of style, Santogold — Santi White's out-of-nowhere 2008 debut —was a very good album that nicked from Tegan and Sara, No Doubt, and reggae-rap, and risked typecasting her even as she defied type. But as a personality or visionary, White's talent is ordinary enough to question how eagerly she's being anticipated four years later. The similarly shape-shifting TV on the Radio's David Sitek helped helm Master of My Make-Believe, and he brought along his friend Karen O for the lead track and easy standout "GO!" It's a nervy and nervous opening track, either too aware or completely indifferent to the ridiculous expectations set up for this four-years-in-the-making follow-up, recalling the let-down of M.I.A.'s last disc. And if you think such comparisons are lazy, just listen to "Fame" and see if they're not justified. But other than repeated exhortations about "a life worth fighting for" on "Disparate Youth," Santigold lives down to the inadequate title, with make-believe, danceable escapism for Urban Outfitters shopping that won't make you question the prices, much less start a riot. Since all we demanded of 2008 tracks "I'm a Lady," "L.E.S. Artistes," and "Lights Out" were catchy tunes, small stakes aren't the problem. We know she traffics in minor techno-reggae and consistently pumping alt-rock. But Sitek's production only makes her seem like more of a shut-in, despite the occasional irresistible glimmer. "The Keepers," for example, has a chorus her more original peers would kill for. Real-world depth and danceable hooks need not be mutually exclusive.

Related: Various Artists | Casual Victim Pile: Austin 2010, Bearstronaut | Broken Handclaps, Avi Buffalo | Avi Buffalo, More more >
  Topics: CD Reviews , Music, Arts, CD reviews,  More more >
| More

Most Popular
Share this entry with Delicious
  •   THE MEN | NEW MOON  |  March 06, 2013
    They're just a band, they insist; they didn't realize that a name as authoritative as the Men makes a band look, well, definitive and self-important.
  •   TORRES | TORRES  |  February 26, 2013
    Twenty-two-year-old Mackenzie Scott's homemade music floats somewhere between the cathedral jangle of 10,000 Maniacs and the buzzy churn of EMA.
  •   RE-ENDTRODUCING DJ SHADOW  |  December 07, 2012
    After a long phone conversation, the last thing I asked Josh Davis, was, if at age 40, he still had something to prove.
    Well, now it's official: the title of every record Nicki Minaj ever makes will include the title of every other record she's ever made.
  •   TITUS ANDRONICUS | LOCAL BUSINESS  |  October 18, 2012
    That intersection of punk and prog isn't new, but the prog/punk back-to-basics album is. Enter Titus Andronicus.

 See all articles by: DAN WEISS