Adding to the confusion

Published May 13 2009, 11:47 AM by Jeff Inglis

Paula Michaud, from up in Aroostook County, called yesterday to ask us to write a story about a book she's working on, called Dirty Decisions. At the moment, she's blogging about her efforts as part of a provocatively named group, JAIL for Judges. (It's an acronym for "Judicial Accountability Initiative Law," an idea that would make the judicial branch "answerable and accountable to an entity other than itself.")

It's an interesting idea, especially given the questions about how judges should be selected. (Here's a fascinating comparison of appointing versus electing judges. Neither's perfect. It's also unclear when elected judges have conflicts of interest that should force them to recuse themselves.)

Unfortunately, Michaud appears to be hurting the effort even in her zeal to support it. Not only did she claim credit for introducing what must be the single least-coherent bill considered by the Maine Legislature this year, but she suggested that the fix is easy: "changing the Constitution by simply enacting it into law."

Ironically, Michaud could probably stand to talk to a judge about how to change the US Constitution and how to amend the Maine Constitution. (Hint: In neither case can lawmakers act alone.)

Filed Under: Paula Michaud, judicial reform

Portland's new "poet laureate" lives in Falmouth

Commuting variations

Follow the Phoenix

All Blogs

Phlog (1,514)
Talking Politics (1,600)
On The Download (2,245)
Laser Orgy (85)
Dont Quote Me (561)
Outside The Frame (326)

Filed Under: Paula Michaud, judicial reform

Boston Phoenix
Adding to the confusion
Published 5/13/2009 by Jeff Inglis
Paula Michaud, from up in Aroostook County, called yesterday to ask us to write a story about a book...

more by Jeff Inglis

Nickelodeon to screen local flicks | February 05, 2010

Starting to clear Maine’s broadband backlog | January 29, 2010

Good starts | January 15, 2010

Helping Haiti | January 14, 2010

Replacing Ted Kennedy | January 13, 2010

See all articles by: Jeff Inglis

Latest Comments

Charlie Baker: More Neanderthal-Conservative Than Romney? - "But reasonable people, particularly those in public political life, do not question the scientific...

By Fake Name on 02-09-2010 in Talking Politics

More Bad Signs For GOP Women - The NRCC has got to get a clue! This is exactly why the GOP constantly loses the female vote among independents...

By Leah Wright on 02-09-2010 in Talking Politics

The Kells in Allston is closing - Thank God. A Tavern in the Square, though? Christ.

By Z on 02-09-2010 in Phlog

Thugs and goons: Howie Carr explains--updated! - Carr got it from the comments omg. Who's less credible carr, barnicle or beck? Remember when journalists...

By neil on 02-09-2010 in Dont Quote Me

Q&A #10 -- Mighty Malone? - Joe Malone is a solid character who connects with the average citizen. No one ever accused him of any...

By smallfish on 02-09-2010 in Talking Politics

Latest Comments from About Town

Adding to the confusion

Leave a Comment