Stooges cover Madonna: Rock Hall not useless after all

Published Mar 11 2008, 07:19 PM by Carly Carioli

What goes around (goes around, goes around) comes all the way back around

We have no idea who pitched who on having the Stooges covering Madonna's "Burning Up" at the RNRHOF induction last night, but we want to have this person inducted into the Rock N Roll hall of fame, and quickly. Ironically, we missed this live last night because we were watching a rerun of last year's "Fashion Rocks," on which the Stooges play "I Wanna Be Your Dog" -- and, later on the same show, the Gossip turn the end of their "Yr Mangled Heart" into an impromtu disco cover of "I Wanna Be Your Dog." (Beth Ditto, prefacing the song: "Madonna said 'Express Yourself'; Morrissey said, 'Accept Yourself'; and RuPaul said, 'You Gotta Work.'") There's no real musical irony here at all. Madonna's original demo version of "Burning Up" made it abundantly clear, even moreso than the official version, that it was more or less a punkish new-wave tune -- which is one reason that punks can't resist covering it. (Said punks include the man playing bass in the Stooges last night -- Mr. Mike Watt, who previously covered "Burning Up," as well as "Into the Groove," with Sonic "Ciccone" Youth back in 1986. Sonic Youth, of course, were also known to cover "I Wanna Be Your Dog.") More to the point, one of the revelations of Madge's return to touring a couple years ago was that she was learning to play guitar -- or at least learning to play just enough that she could sneak into the set a version of "I Love New York" that quotes explicitly from (wait for it) "I Wanna Be Your Dog," in which song she also tended to scream, Iggy-like, things such as "Fuck off!" and "Go suck George Bush's dick!" We hope someone gets a better clip of the Stooges' Madonna set on YT quickly. And someone should get the live tracks added to iTunes or something. Kthxbai!

Stooges, "Burnin Up (Live 2008)." (With Horatio Sans on guitar? And Madonna, in the front row, suddenly realizing that this is awful close to what she's going to look like in 15 years?)

Gossip, "Yr Mangled Heart/I Wanna Be Your Dog" (Live 2007)

Madonna, "I Love New York/I Wanna Be Your Dog" (Live 2006)

Attachment: http://thephoenix.com/onthedownload/content/binary/iggymadonnajt.bmp

Filed Under: awesomeness, bands from the 70s that we never thought would play a good show again, Pop, Rocknroll, Video

MP3 of the Week: Aloud

Happy Sigur Rós day!!!

1 Comments

Ryan said:

Am I to understand that Leonard Cohen didn't perform, he just read poetry?

March 12, 2008 2:03 PM

Follow the Phoenix

All Blogs

On The Download (2,354)
Outside The Frame (341)
Laser Orgy (108)
Phlog (1,548)
Talking Politics (1,646)
Dont Quote Me (581)

Filed Under: awesomeness, bands from the 70s that we never thought would play a good show again, Pop, Rocknroll, Video

Boston Phoenix
A brief discussion of that Beach House video on Pitchfork today
Published 2/1/2010 by Ryan Stewart
So, okay. BEACH HOUSE, who, to be clear, we love, are apparently doing a weeklong "special presentation" for the Fork, purportedly from their practice space...

Boston Phoenix
Ya herd? Extreme sheep LED art
Published 7/28/2009 by Shaula Clark
Samsung can shovel ads down my throat for the rest of eternity, as long as they're all as magnificent as this:

more by Carly Carioli

SXSW 2010 (Wednesday): Freelance Whales, Basia Bulat, Horse Feathers, High on Fire | March 18, 2010

Overnight sensation Boston rapper Sam Adams debuts at #7 rap album, #71 overall, on Billboard | March 11, 2010

Dinosaur Jr.'s J Mascis to debut two new bands -- one with Thurston Moore and Andrew W.K. -- at SXSW | March 11, 2010

Video premiere: exclusive Silversun Pickups performance at Boston's Ames Hotel | March 11, 2010

VIDEO: Dropkick Murphys partner with SPIN, Warner Bros, AP, Major League Baseball, and AOL for live-album publicity blitz | March 10, 2010

See all articles by: Carly Carioli