Horrifyingly terrible idea of the day: US remake of Oldboy

Published Nov 07 2008, 10:28 AM by Ryan Stewart

Off the top of my head, I'd say that Korea's Oldboy is probably one of the best films of this decade. For those who haven't seen it yet, it centers around a man incarcerated in his apartment for fifteen years, by an unknown tormentor, for reasons that are unclear to him, and his search for vengeance and answers upon his release. It's alternatingly fist-pumping, brutal, disturbing, and weirdly sweet. It's a unique, creative, groundbreaking, amazing film that has earned a lot of respect from discerning viewers, including our own Peter Keough.

So, of course, Hollywood wants to remake it. Those who have seen the film will instantly recognize this as a bad idea. To the rest, the film's central story arc involves a significant plot twist that I would not dare reveal to those who haven't seen the film. But it's that twist that's going to make this such a difficult sell to mainstream U. S. audience. Especially when you consider who's in talks to climb on board this vehicle: Steven Spielberg and Will Smith. Can President-Elect Obama step in on this or something?

Filed Under: Blunt Object, bad ideas, Movies

Today's Cares/Who Cares on WFNX

Obama wins; people get naked

Follow the Phoenix

All Blogs

Phlog (1,544)
Talking Politics (1,645)
Laser Orgy (106)
On The Download (2,293)
Outside The Frame (339)
Dont Quote Me (581)

Filed Under: Blunt Object, bad ideas, Movies

Boston Phoenix
Horrifyingly terrible idea of the day: US remake of Oldboy
Published 11/7/2008 by Ryan Stewart
Off the top of my head, I'd say that Korea's Oldboy is probably one of the best films of this decade. For those who haven't...

Boston Phoenix
"Blunt Object" Follow-Up: Attorney General Coakley Responds To Question 2 Marijuana Reformers
Published 9/30/2008 by Chris Faraone
In my recent Phoenix article, “Blunt Object,” regarding Commonwealth marijuana reform, I guessed that Attorney General Martha Coakley would decline to scold the Massachusetts District...

more by Ryan Stewart

VIDEO: The National debuts a track from High Violet | March 11, 2010

New MGMT, "Flash Delerium" | March 09, 2010

Pavement playing Boston on September 18 at the Agganis Arena (tickets on sale March 12) | March 01, 2010

FYI: Thom Yorke has renamed his band and they're playing Boston on April 8. Tickets on sale next week! | February 25, 2010

Team Conan update: joining Twitter, doing it live | February 25, 2010

See all articles by: Ryan Stewart

Latest Comments

Another HBO trailer, this time for "Boardwalk Empire" - <a href= imgwebsearch.com/.../imgcheap flights/cheap%20flights/1_air1.png</IMG></a>

By Headesype on 03-16-2010 in Phlog

Tron Legacy: Serious Business - Haha. All right, fine.

By Maddy Myers on 03-15-2010 in Laser Orgy

WIN tickets to see the Black Eyed Peas - I love them soooooo much. <33333333 They ROCK!!!!<33333333333333333333

By Mickie on 03-15-2010 in On The Download

GOP 2012 Rankings, Updated 3/1/10 - this is a very silly list and it doesn't account for how GOP primaries are really won. the establishment...

By max on 03-15-2010 in Talking Politics

Cambridge Rapper Sam Adams Debuts At Number One On iTunes - @JV: He's originally from Cambridge. He lived on Pleasant Pl, right behind his elementary school...

By Johnny K on 03-15-2010 in On The Download

Latest Comments from Phlog

Horrifyingly terrible idea of the day: US remake of Oldboy

Leave a Comment