The Phoenix Network:
 
 
About  |  Advertise
Adult  |  Moonsigns  |  Band Guide  |  Blogs  |  In Pictures
 
GG-1000x50

British newspapers out alleged WikiLeaks source, a soldier, as being gay; Queer-bashing has already begun

Buried in the last few paragraphs of a long story, the UK's Daily Mail quotes a friend of BRADLEY MANNING thusly: "‘He was different from other kids. He was interested in girls but he could never really get them to be interested in him. When he was 13, he told me he was gay.’"

Over the weekend, the British Daily Telegraph described Manning as "openly homosexual," and delved into his Facebook account to retrieve a status update referring to "an ex-boyfriend" as well as a photo of Manning, at a gay-rights rally, holding a placard that demands LGBT rights on the battlefield.

The American mainstream media has carefully tip-toed around the question of Manning's sexuality -- although blogs including BOING BOING have for at least a month openly asked whether the transcript of Manning's IM chats (the ones that got him arrested by the army on suspicion of delivering tens of thousands of secret documents to WikiLeaks) indicate that Manning is transgendered. The same Boing Boing post questions whether Manning's sexuality led to his downfall, via his trust of the Boston native and famous hacker in whom Manning confided, and who later turned Manning in to the Feds:

"Did Manning, in isolation and distress while stationed in Iraq, reach out to Adrian Lamo in part because Manning believed Lamo —whom the internet-searchable public record shows has been an active member of the LGBT community—would be empathetic to a fellow geek going through a gender identity crisis?"

In June, Gawker -- citing the GLBT links on Manning's Facebook profile -- asked pretty much the same question: "Was WikiLeaker Bradley Manning betrayed by his queer identity?"

The Daily Mail's article was ostensibly about the suffering of Manning's English mother -- who was questioned by FBI agents over the weekend -- but the Mail also took the opportunity to run a big photo of Manning being embraced by Tyler Watkins, one of Manning's openly-gay Boston friends who has reportedly been questioned by the Army in recent weeks. Watkins, a Boston University student and former marketing intern at EDGE who was quoted in Wired magazine's original scoop, is now politely declining all media inquiries. His blog -- "Swish Army" -- identifies him as a "queer army wife": "It wasn’t until I join the ranks of all the other gay military spouses that I really ever understood how unjust our country’s policies towards the queer community in the military," he writes. "Not only am I fed up with DADT but I’m sick and tired of the Obama administration’s failure to serve and uphold the rights of ALL citizens of the US."

Why is any of this relevant?

Because the right wing is already using Manning's sexuality to bash the idea of gays in the military. And because it's probably going to get a lot worse.

Here's Right Side News, in a post titled "Military Homosexual Scandal Tied to WikiLeaks Treason":

The revelations of Manning's openly pro-homosexual conduct suggest that a more liberal Department of Defense policy, in deference to the wishes of the Commander-in-Chief, had already been in effect and has now backfired in a big way. The result could be not only the loss of the lives of U.S. soldiers, as a result of the enemy understanding U.S. intelligence sources and methods, but damaged relations with Afghanistan and Pakistan and a possible U.S.military defeat in the region as a whole. 

In other words: look for the right to spin WikiLeaks not as a free-speech debate or a referendum on a failed US policy in Afghanistan but as a referendum on Don't Ask Don't Tell, and a horror story about the treasonous collaboration of a venegeful queer, an ineffectual president, and the liberal media.

Here's some more from Right Side News: 

The dramatic revelations about Manning's circle of friends and associates suggest that, rather than repeal the homosexual exclusion policy, as Obama is demanding, the prohibition on homosexuals should have been more strictly enforced and that it should be strengthened today. What's more, it is clear that Manning should have been expelled from the Armed Forces long before he allegedly did his damage to U.S. national security . . . This is important because the Manning scandal provides ammunition to those who want to maintain the exclusion of homosexuals from themilitary . It proves in dramatic terms that homosexuals with gender identity disorders are potentially unstable and that their strange sexual preferences can subvert the military mission and cost lives.

Is this a case where the MSM played its sensitivities way too straight? By not bringing up Manning's sexuality, the New York Times and the AP likely hoped to prevent exactly the kind of vicious stereotyping that the Right is engaging in now -- but they also ceded the discussion to the dark digital caves where bigots congregate. They also added fuel to the rampant conservative opinion that the liberal media is "protecting" gays -- thereby strengthening a perception of bias. As British outlets continue to break news that suggests Manning was deeply disillusioned by his military experiences -- not only the conduct of the war but also, it appears, the military's policies towards LGBT servicepeople -- American mainstream news outlets are going to have to answer for why they under-reported Manning's identity.

| More

2 Comments

  • Itstheorientation said:

    What is the benefit to our country of "queer army wives"?  Able-bodied men who don't work?  Able-bodied men who are prohibited from donating blood for fear of their contaminating the blood supply? Able-bodied men driving up the cost of health insurance by their irresponsible and predatory sexual behavior that makes them candidates for AIDS, STDs, and drug addiction? Able-bodied men proud of contributing public nudity and sadism to our society?

    Are these people fit parents?

    images.search.yahoo.com/.../i

    mages;_ylt=A0geu17gtzxM7mUBixJXNyoA?

    ei=UTF-8&p=gay%20pride&fr2=tab-

    web&fr=yfp-t-892

    Facts about homosexuality:

    www.freerepublic.com/.../news

    2478047/posts

    www.conservapedia.com/Homosexual

    ity_Statistics

    www.abovetopsecret.com/.../thr

    ead509659/pg1

    August 3, 2010 1:32 PM
  • JDW said:

    Why it is seemingly okay for this man to illegally leak classified information, but it is beyond the pale to point out he was gay? The Facebook posts and some of the correspondences he had with others indicate much of his motivation for revealing classified information was because of the DADT policy. The Phoenix will have a hard time convincing many people that this man can leak all this sensitive information that potentially puts many people at risk, but finding out information about him is unacceptable.

    August 9, 2010 8:19 AM

Leave a Comment

Login | Not a member yet? Click here to Join
 Friends' Activity   Popular   Most Viewed 
All Blogs
ADVERTISEMENT
Related Articles

Boston Phoenix
British newspapers out alleged WikiLeaks source, a soldier, as being gay; Queer-bashing has already begun
Published 8/2/2010 by Carly Carioli
Buried in the last few paragraphs of a long story, the UK's Daily Mail quotes a friend of BRADLEY MANNING thusly: "‘He was different from...

Boston Phoenix
WikiLeaks, MIT, and Lady Gaga: A Guide to Boston's Role in Yet Another National Security Breach
Published 7/31/2010 by Carly Carioli
Cambridge's elite academic institutions enjoy a friendly rivalry, but this is getting ridiculous, no? Sure, that deported Russian spy had a degree from Harvard's Kenedy...

more by Carly Carioli
Julian Assange has been reported to the cyberpolice | December 08, 2010
Why you should watch tonight's Jets-Patriots game with your laptop open | December 06, 2010
Boston's most notorious punk-rock gang leader lands debut film in competition at 2011 Sundance Film Festival | December 01, 2010
John Kerry's cameo in the Wikileaks State Department cable dump | November 28, 2010
Maddow to media: come out of the closet | November 19, 2010

 See all articles by: Carly Carioli

Follow the Phoenix
  • newsletter
  • twitter
  • facebook
  • youtube
  • rss
Latest Comments
One Wrecking Ball Minimum: All Asia Cafe closing? - Hey guys! We may be leaving the physical space, at 334 Mass Ave, next year, but we will be moving close...

By Marc Shulman on 12-10-2010 in On The Download

Ticket on-sale alert: NKOTB/BSB, Lauryn Hill, Bon Jovi, Elton John, Aziz Ansari, Neko Case, and more - Omg! Now I feel old this sure brings back memories down memory lane!

By fb1659024135 on 12-10-2010 in On The Download

WFNX Boston Accents playlist 11.28.10: 2010 Boston Music Awards edition - Boo no Army of Toys!

By Jen on 12-06-2010 in On The Download

Gears of War 3: Female Character Added, Game Ruined - Well I've heard it's "confirmed" there's a Sam Byrne in Gears 3, and the blonde...

By paradox4 on 12-05-2010 in Laser Orgy

Gears of War 3: Female Character Added, Game Ruined - Its about time for female character! Maddy Myers you little idiot go fuck yourself!

By works4me on 12-03-2010 in Laser Orgy

Latest Comments from Phlog
Most Viewed
Burn of the week, courtesy of Julia Child
Liveblogging Franzen on Oprah
NYC Guerrilla Literary Reading
Deep Heaven Now II crashes Somerville
[Q&A] Nick Cave on getting primal with Grinderman, wasting time in Hollywoodland, and dealing with Robert Fripp
WFNX Boston Accents playlist 11.14.10
Best song about a baby monkey riding backwards on a pig... EVER.
Most Viewed from Phlog
Search Blogs
 
Phlog Archives
Sunday, December 12, 2010  |  Sign In  |  Register
 
TODAY'S FEATURED ADVERTISERS
thePhoenix.com
Phoenix Media/Communications Group
Copyright © 2010 The Phoenix Media/Communications Group