Scattered Trees | Sympathy

(Roll Call/EMI 2011)
By RYAN REED  |  April 6, 2011
2.0 2.0 Stars

the real Scattered trees main
On "Love and Leave," a painfully straightforward alt-guitar ballad on an album full of painfully straightforward alt-guitar ballads, Chicago's Scattered Trees can't decide which early-period Chris Martin moment they'd like to ape. Some may call them a poor man's Coldplay — which would make them, according to some, a poor man's poor man's Radiohead. Sometimes they just sound like poor men. Although Scattered Trees get emotionally expansive throughout this full-length debut, there's a distinct lack of production (and even playing) here, and that colors the proceedings with an anonymous hue. You keep waiting for those "Eureka!" moments in these inoffensive, safely crowd-pleasing tunes; you keep holding out for the band to rip down the electric-guitar wallpaper, for some energy to creep in, for something to challenge you or at least kick up a little dust. But those moments are rare. Yes, the restraint can work to the band's benefit, as on "Bury the Floors," where stark harmonies and droning synth build nervous tension that's more satisfying (and interesting) than an explosive catharsis. It could have turned into "Fix You (Again)," but they resisted the easy temptation. Still, that particular negative virtue is not enough. Even when Scattered Trees aim for the rainbow, things turn out a bit "Yellow."
  Topics: CD Reviews , CD reviews, Pop, Sympathy
| More


Most Popular
ARTICLES BY RYAN REED
Share this entry with Delicious
  •   WAVVES | AFRAID OF HEIGHTS  |  March 18, 2013
    "I Can't Dream," the closer on Wavves' fourth studio album, opens in a drunken lo-fi stupor — Nathan Williams warbling bratty, tone-deaf nonsense over hissy acoustic power chords.
  •   THE VIRGINS | STRIKE GENTLY  |  March 06, 2013
    After a half-decade of semi-obscurity, frontman Donald Cumming is redefining his band as the hipster sultans of swing.
  •   ATOMS FOR PEACE | AMOK  |  February 26, 2013
    Kid A , Radiohead's confounding electro-rock masterpiece, is officially hitting puberty.
  •   ATLAS GENIUS | WHEN IT WAS NOW  |  February 20, 2013
    Atlas Genius are schooled students of modern pop architecture, seamlessly bouncing from Coldplay-styled acoustic rock to fizzy Phoenix funkiness to deadpanned Strokes-ian guitar chug. But When It Was Now is more like an alt-pop NOW compilation than a joyous synthesis.
  •   FOALS | HOLY FIRE  |  February 11, 2013
    Even at their most expansive, Foals are digging into more primal territory.

 See all articles by: RYAN REED