CD Reviews

Sonic Youth | The Eternal

Matador (2009)

By MICHAEL PATRICK BRADY | June 1, 2009

2.5 Stars

Listen:Sonic Youth, "Sacred Trickster" (mp3)

This is Sonic Youth's first release on Matador Records, a retirement home for long-in-the-tooth indie-rockers, after two decades of major-label albums and one celebrity-curated Starbucks hits compilation. Maybe discovering that Beck's favorite Sonic Youth song is "Sugar Kane" threw them for a loop, because The Eternal abandons the comfortable maturity of their three previous excellent records in favor of the throwback '90s sound of Dirty. They've even let throwback '90s bassist Mark Ibold join the band as a full member.

What it lacks in depth, the release makes up for in spirit. "Sacred Trickster" and "Thunderclap" are infectious rockers that don't belabor the point; each expires after two minutes. "Anti-Orgasm" tosses off lyrical platitudes with an earnest rebellion that should be reserved for teenagers; it's saved by a hard-edged guitar squall and the novelty of the shared vocals from Thurston and Kim.

The best tracks, "What We Know" and "Walkin Blues," are, no surprise, from the reliable Lee Ranaldo. His voice is clear and confident, and the songs possess a strength and dignity that befit a songwriter of his stature and age. The Eternal is a fun, superficial tangent, disappointing in its regressiveness but enjoyable as long you don't examine it too closely.

Topics: CD Reviews , Entertainment, Music, Pop and Rock Music, More

| More

ARTICLES BY MICHAEL PATRICK BRADY

THE FALL | YOUR FUTURE OUR CLUTTER | April 27, 2010
If you didn’t know any better, you might think that Your Future Our Clutter is a recording of a raving old lunatic heckling a very solid instrumental band.

SAM AMIDON | I SEE THE SIGN | April 15, 2010
Sam Amidon is fascinated with the songbook of old Americana, and his radical yet tasteful reimaginings of traditional folk ballads and hymns breathe new life into a form often seen as quaint and old-fashioned.

RED SPAROWES | THE FEAR IS EXCRUCIATING, BUT THEREIN LIES THE ANSWER | March 30, 2010
Post-rock bands are like silent-film actors — bereft of words, they tend to use broad gestures to ensure that you get the point.

THESE NEW PURITANS | HIDDEN | March 09, 2010
Hidden is a real UK horror show, mixing grim, industrial beats with mannered, regal horns and a persistent aura of foggy uneasiness. These New Puritans reveal a penchant for æsthetic violence and revolutionary action that, though rarely convincing, matches the uncompromising intensity and martial tenor of the music.