Against nativism

Published Apr 21 2006, 02:59 PM by Adam Reilly

Aaron at Mass Democracy raises an interesting question: is it better to have a governor who was born in Massachusetts? His answer is a resounding yes--but he doesn't back up his argument.

Not to be harsh, but maybe that's because it doesn't make much sense.

Don't get me wrong. If a candidate whose attachment to Massachusetts is questionable picks our state for expediency's sake (see: Mitt Romney, 2002), it's valid to point that out. But that doesn't seem to be the case with Deval Patrick or Chris Gabrieli or Kerry Healey. They all have deep ties to Massachusetts, and decided to make their lives here long before opting to run for governor. Does the fact they were born in IL and NY and FL, respectively, mean they're less emotionally attached to MA than someone who's lived here their entire life? Or that they're somehow less capable of understanding the state's problems than a native?

I just don't get it. But maybe that's because (gasp!) I was born in NH and grew up in MN.

St. Patrick, indeed

Greatest Romney gaffes--add your own!

1 Comments

Aaron said:

Thanks for the shout-out, I guess. It is indeed fair to point out that all three candidates in question have longer-standing ties to Massachusetts than did Romney. And in my post, I noted that this is really not the most important thing in choosing a Governor. However, there are a lot of little, not-very substantive things to look at when choosing a candidate in addition to policy matters, such as where they from, where they live, how open they are about their finances, etc. They may not matter as much as other things, but I feel they can be a good indication of the person's character. Part of my point was that virtually all of those little things are stacked in Reilly's corner, which I think is at least noteworthy.

April 24, 2006 3:10 AM

Follow the Boston Phoenix

All Blogs

On The Download (2,174)
Dont Quote Me (525)
Talking Politics (1,529)
Outside The Frame (307)
Phlog (1,430)
Laser Orgy (35)

more by Adam Reilly

Goal rush! | December 04, 2009

Greg Epstein, Atheist Superstar | November 27, 2009

Unmaking a bad federal law | November 27, 2009

Collateral damage? | November 13, 2009

Holy terror? | November 13, 2009

See all articles by: Adam Reilly

Latest Comments

City Council Forums - Наш сайт - самый легкий и быстрый способ найти партнера, имеющего схожие с вашими сексуальные предпочтения...

By Merbactibrape on 12-04-2009 in Talking Politics

Totten trial chairwoman: the fix wasn't in - Hi !. You re, I guess , probably curious to know how one can make real money . There is no initial capital...

By EpirummomoHug on 12-04-2009 in Dont Quote Me

Recommended reading: Charlie Pierce on Tiger Woods - Mike Hunt's Q&A Session: Q: What is only way Tiger will get thru this? A: Tiger will have to go on...

By Mike Hunt on 12-03-2009 in Dont Quote Me

Confirmation Of Contradiction - If Coakley's poll was a smaller margin, but still bigger than what Capuano's poll is seeing it would...

By This guy on 12-03-2009 in Talking Politics

Recommended reading: Charlie Pierce on Tiger Woods - @ Mike Harter: Mike, Charlie's point is that USGA bows daily at the altar of El Tigre, the man-child...

By Mike Saunders on 12-03-2009 in Dont Quote Me

Latest Comments from Talking Politics

Against nativism

1 Comments

Aaron said:

Leave a Comment